Customised Investment
The current investment module can only track portfolios with formal stock tickers. It would be very helpful to allow users to create manual investment items within an investment portfolio.
This can serve the purposes of: 1) tracking investment items which don’t have tickers (like US T-bills); 2) tracking pension funds etc which are not traded in the public market.
Otherwise we are “forced” to keep these items under the “Bank/Asset” segment, then the calculation of investment performance, FIRE etc are not correct.
Log in to comment and vote
Comments9
luca95b
Nov 10
You should have a look to securo-finance. They already support manual investment items, manual price updates and the possibility to add new entry to existing items.
https://github.com/securo-finance/securo
dmytro_sv
Nov 11
Sure, thanks for the reference !
Emanuel
Oct 24
https://github.com/lorenzodotta02/Finance-functions-for-Google-Sheets - this one worked for me, maybe we can integrate that one in money matter?
dmytro_sv
Oct 24
Thanks, I’ll take a look into it once I’ll start working on this feature 🙏
Emanuel
Oct 23
Yes this would actually be a great workaround for Bonds. I am also struggling with it right now. Maybe also adding a way to add a price ticker manually? Like I know about some bonds, where the stock exchanges give current prices but yahoo doesn’t.
dmytro_sv
Oct 24
Custom tickets will probably have an option to upload prices for them, yes. Yet I didn’t even start looking into it, busy with iOS app atm, so I have no idea how it will look like in the final version
dmytro_sv
Oct 1
How do you expect to track the price of such custom tickers? I can only think of manual price updates by the user. So it would all be scoped per user: the custom security's ticker, its price updates, events like dividends, etc.
If you have seen this flow implemented elsewhere, could you please share a reference so I won't reinvent the wheel? 🙂
pxzjnm
Oct 1
Yes. It can be all managed/updated by the user. Very basic functions can already be helpful.
I haven’t seen a similar flow in the modern solutions yet - most of them are quite similar to what you implement now. But in the “good old days” when using Microsoft Money and Quicken, they did allow manual creation and update of investment items.
dmytro_sv
Oct 1
Okie, thanks for the details. It’s indeed a very helpful feature, I kinda need it for myself too, and some other users already requested it for crypto. Just was out of priorities due to lack of votes, but I’ll see the combined votes of all related tickets to reprioritize 👍